SB0560

SENATE BILL 560

54th legislature - STATE OF NEW MEXICO - first session, 2019

INTRODUCED BY

Antoinette Sedillo-Lopez

AN ACT

RELATING TO WATER; REFORMING THE GENERAL POWERS OF THE INTERSTATE STREAM COMMISSION TO INCLUDE WATER PLANNING; ENACTING THE REGIONAL WATER PLANNING ACT; PROVIDING CRITERIA AND DIRECTION FOR STATE AND REGIONAL WATER PLANNING; PROVIDING POWERS AND DUTIES; MAKING AN APPROPRIATION.

BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF NEW MEXICO:

SECTION 1. Section 72-14-3 NMSA 1978 (being Laws 1935, Chapter 25, Section 3) is amended to read:

"72-14-3. INTERSTATE STREAM COMMISSION--GENERAL POWERS-- INTERSTATE COMPACTS--EMPLOYEES--ATTORNEY GENERAL'S DUTIES.-- [That said]

A. The interstate stream commission [is hereby authorized to] shall:

(1) negotiate compacts, [with other states] to settle interstate controversies or [looking toward] provide for an equitable distribution and division of waters in interstate stream systems and ground waters, subject, in all cases, to final approval by the legislature of New Mexico; [to]

(2) plan and implement state programs or match appropriations made by the congress of the United States for federal investigations [looking to the development] or programs related to the conservation or protection of water supplies and the flows of interstate streams originating in or flowing through the state [of New Mexico; to investigate] for the people, future generations and species that depend on them;

(3) quantify ground water and surface water [supply; to] supplies that are legally and physically available;

(4) develop, [to] conserve, [to] protect and [to] do any and all other things necessary to protect, conserve and develop the waters, ground waters and stream systems of this state, interstate or otherwise; [to]

(5) publicly and transparently conduct state and regional water planning to plan for the state's water future; to identify the steps needed to be taken to protect and extend water supplies; and to make water usage in the state more resilient;

(6) advise the state engineer;

(7) institute or cause to be instituted in the name of the state [of New Mexico] any and all negotiations [and/or] or legal proceedings as in its judgment are necessary to carry out the provisions of [this Act; to] Chapter 72, Article 14 NMSA 1978;

(8) do all other things necessary to carry out the provisions of [this Act; to] Chapter 72, Article 14 NMSA 1978;

(9) employ such attorneys, engineers, water professionals and clerical help as, in its judgment, may be necessary to carry out the provisions of [this Act] Chapter 72, Article 14 NMSA 1978 and to fix their compensation and expenses; [together with] and

(10) exercise such other powers and duties as may, from time to time, be given [said] the commission by the legislature [of New Mexico].

B. The attorney general shall be the legal adviser of [such] the commission and attorneys employed [as above] shall be subject to [his] the attorney general's approval and supervision and be designated as special assistant attorneys general."

SECTION 2. Section 72-14-3.1 NMSA 1978 (being Laws 2003, Chapter 131, Section 1 and Laws 2003, Chapter 137, Section 1) is amended to read:

"72-14-3.1. STATE WATER PLAN--PURPOSE--CONTENTS.--

A. It is the intent of the legislature that the

interstate stream commission, in collaboration with the office of the state engineer and the water trust board, prepare and implement a comprehensive state water plan.

B. The state water plan shall address the following goals and shall be a strategic management tool for the purposes of:

(1) identifying steps needed for and promoting stewardship of the state's water resources;

(2) protecting and maintaining water rights and their priority status;

(3) protecting the diverse customs, culture, environment and economic stability of the state;

(4) protecting both the water supply and water quality;

(5) [promoting] developing and facilitating the implementation of cooperative strategies, based on concern for meeting the basic needs of all New Mexicans;

(6) meeting the state's interstate compact obligations;

(7) [providing] developing and implementing a basis for prioritizing infrastructure investment; and

(8) providing statewide continuity of policy and management to improve the public welfare relative to [our] the state's water resources.

C. The interstate stream commission in collaboration with the office of the state engineer and in consultation with other government agencies as appropriate, shall develop a comprehensive, coordinated, fact- and science-based state water plan that shall:

(1) identify and reflect the common priorities, goals and objectives that will have a positive impact on the public welfare of the state;

(2) establish a clear vision and policy direction for active management of the state's waters at appropriate regional and sub-regional scales based on hydrologic and legal realities with an emphasis on solving water-related problems at local and basinwide scales, including identifying and developing cooperative strategies and policies that address the gaps between water demand and the physically and legally available water supply to meet the demand;

(3) include an inventory of the quantity and quality of the state's water resources, population projections and [other] water resource demands, historical trends and potential future trends under a range of forecast conditions that recognize climate change and aridification;

(4) include historical and projected future water budgets [for the state and] for all major river basins and [aquifer] ground water systems in the state and prioritize plans to improve the reliability of those water budgets, if needed;

(5) develop water conservation strategies and policies to [maximize] stop waste of water, to encourage the efficient use of water resources and to minimize the amount of water required to satisfy beneficial [use, including reuse and recycling by conjunctive management of water resources and by doing so to promote nonforfeiture of water rights] uses;

(6) develop strategies to increase the longevity of ground water resources that are in decline;

(7) develop strategies to aid compliance with interstate stream compacts while protecting the public welfare of the state and identify federal resources to assist with implementation of those strategies;

[(6)] (8) include a drought management plan designed to address drought emergencies, promote strategies for prevention of drought-related emergencies in the future and coordinate regional and local drought planning statewide;

[(7)] (9) recognize the relationship between water availability and land-use decisions;

[(8)] (10) promote river riparian and watershed restoration that focuses on protecting the water supply, improving water quality and complying with federal Endangered Species Act of 1973 mandates;

[(9)] (11) consider water rights transfer policies that balance the need to protect the customs, culture, environment and economic health and stability of the state's diverse communities while providing for timely and efficient transfers of water between uses to meet both short-term shortages and long-term economic development needs;

[(10)] (12) promote strategies and mechanisms for achieving coordination [with] among all levels of government;

[(11)] (13) integrate approved regional water plans into the state water plan as appropriate and consistent with state water plan policies and strategies;

[(12)] (14) integrate plans of water supply purveyors, including those of local governments, privately owned public utilities, associations, cooperatives, irrigation districts and acequias as appropriate and consistent with state water plan policies and strategies, as those plans are completed and submitted to the office of the state engineer;

[(13)] (15) identify water-related infrastructure and management investment needs and opportunities to leverage federal and other funding; [and

(14)] (16) promote collaboration with and strategic focusing of the research and development of the state's national laboratories and research institutions to address the state's water challenges and to bring to the state demonstration projects in desalination, conservation, watershed restoration, weather modification and other technological approaches to enhancing water supply and management;

[D. Recognizing that complete water rights adjudication, measurement, well inventories and adequate databases are essential elements of an effective water management plan, and further recognizing that completion of these work elements will require substantial time and resources until such time as these elements are complete, the state water plan shall include work plans and strategies for:

(1) completion of water rights adjudications, with required supporting documentation, including hydrographic surveys, aquifer mapping and aerial mapping of irrigated land;

(2) creation and completion of a comprehensive database and an electronically accessible information system on the state's water resources and water rights, including file abstraction and imaging of paper files as well as information on pending adjudications;

(3) measuring of surface and ground water uses in the state as necessary for management of the state's water resources; and

(4) taking inventory of existing water wells and determining appropriate disposition of unused wells.]

(17) address the accuracy, adequacy and limitations of data and models used in developing the state water plan and include a prioritized plan to improve the data and models; and

(18) set forth policies and strategies to effectuate the goals of the state water plan and prioritize the implementation of those policies and strategies.

[E.] D. The interstate stream commission and the office of the state engineer in accordance with the State-Tribal Collaboration Act shall consult directly with the governments of Indian nations, tribes and pueblos to formulate a statement of policy and process to guide:

(1) participation of Indian nations, tribes and pueblos, as they desire, in the regional water planning process;

[(1)] (2) coordination or integration of the water plans of Indian nations, tribes and pueblos located wholly or partially within New Mexico with the state water plan; [and

(2)] (3) final adjudication or settlement of all water rights claims by Indian nations, tribes and pueblos located wholly or partially within New Mexico; and

(4) New Mexico's compliance with interstate stream compacts, recognizing that the compacts shall not affect or impair the water rights of Indian nations, tribes and pueblos located wholly or partially within New Mexico.

[F.] E. The interstate stream commission shall:

(1) ensure that public participation, [and] public input and transparency are integrated throughout the planning process; [The interstate stream commission shall] (2) convene water planners and stakeholders from diverse constituencies to advise it and the office of the state engineer on the state water plan, including statewide policies, priorities, goals and objectives for the plan, issues of statewide concern and strategies for implementation of the plan; [The interstate stream commission shall also]

(3) ensure that representatives of the stakeholder groups affected by various plan components [will] participate in the development of those plan components; (4) notify and invite members of the interstate stream commission and water trust board [shall be notified of and are welcome] to participate in all aspects of the planning process; and

(5) ensure that meetings involving a member of the interstate stream commission convened for the purpose of developing the state water plan or any component of the state water plan comply with the Open Meetings Act and that the minutes of a meeting reflect the substance of the meeting discussion, including the rationale for inclusion or exclusion in the state water plan of any policies or priorities discussed.

[G.] F. After public review and comment, the state water plan developed in conformance with this section is subject to adoption by the interstate stream commission. Following its adoption, the state water plan shall be presented to the interim legislative committee that studies water and natural resources.

[H.] G. The state water plan shall be periodically reviewed, updated and amended in response to changing conditions. At a minimum a review shall be undertaken every five years. Subsequent reviews of the state water plan shall reflect on and address the successes or failures of implementation plans and priorities established in an immediately preceding state water plan.

[I.] H. Nothing in the state water plan shall be construed to permit the granting or the condemnation of water rights.

[J.] I. Nothing in the state water plan shall be construed to determine, abridge or affect the water rights of acequias or Indian nations, tribes or pueblos."

SECTION 3. A new section of Chapter 72, Article 14 NMSA 1978 is enacted to read:

"[NEW MATERIAL] SHORT TITLE.--Sections 3 through 12 of this act may be cited as the "Regional Water Planning Act"."

SECTION 4. Section 72-14-43 NMSA 1978 (being Laws 1987, Chapter 182, Section 1) is recompiled in the Regional Water Planning Act and is amended to read:

"[LEGISLATIVE FINDINGS--STATE APPROPRIATION OF UNAPPROPRIATED WATER] INTERSTATE STREAM COMMISSION--REGIONAL WATER PLANNING PROGRAM.--[Based upon the findings and recommendations of the report from New Mexico state university and the university of New Mexico on state appropriation of unappropriated water, the legislature finds that:

A. the future water needs of New Mexico can best be met by allowing each region of the state to plan for its water future;

B. the state can assist the regions in planning future water use by implementing a state appropriation program to ensure an adequate supply of water for each region, as reflected in each region's water use plan; and

C. the interstate stream commission is the appropriate agency to implement such a program] The interstate stream commission shall:

A. determine how to best meet the future water needs of New Mexico by conducting a regional water planning program that encourages and allows each region of the state to plan for its water future;

B. provide professional and financial support to assist each region in the state with planning future water use and implement programs to ensure an adequate supply of water for each region, as set forth in each region's approved water plan; and

C. fund, facilitate, review and approve regional and sub-regional water plans and actively support implementation of recommendations that require state action."

SECTION 5. Section 72-14-44 NMSA 1978 (being Laws 1987, Chapter 182, Section 2) is recompiled in the Regional Water Planning Act and is amended to read:

"INTERSTATE STREAM COMMISSION--[GROUNDWATER] GROUND WATER APPROPRIATION--WATER RIGHTS PURCHASE [WATER PLANNING FUNDING].--

A. The interstate stream commission is authorized to appropriate [groundwater] ground water or purchase water rights on behalf of any of the various regions of the state.

B. Nothing in [this section] the Regional Water Planning Act shall be construed as permitting the condemnation of water rights or as determining, abridging or affecting in any way the water rights of acequias or Indian nations, tribes or pueblos.

[C. The interstate stream commission is authorized to make grants or loans of funds for the purpose of regional water planning. Prior to approval of any proposal by a region for planning funds under this section, the commission shall develop criteria for evaluating such proposals. These criteria at a minimum shall provide for:

(1) identification of the region requesting planning funds and why it is hydrologically and politically an appropriate applicant;

(2) use of an appropriate planning process, including opportunities for participation by those Indian tribes located within the various regions of the state;

(3) reasonable proposed costs and timetables for completion of the planning process;

(4) appropriate provisions for notice, review and comment where applicable;

(5) adequate review of potential conflict with laws relating to impact on existing water rights;

(6) adequate review of water conservation and the effect on the public welfare; and

(7) identification of sources other than the interstate stream commission for funding of the proposed regional planning process.

D. A water planning region eligible for funding under this section is an area within the state that contains sufficient hydrological and political interests in common to make water planning feasible. The state as a whole shall not be considered a water planning region for purposes of this section.

E. No entity shall be made a part of a proposal for planning funds under this section without its consent.

F. No funds shall be granted under this act to any party or parties that are not within a water planning region. Whether a proposal for funding falls within a water planning region shall be determined on a case-by-case basis by the interstate stream commission after consultation with the state engineer and consideration of the following:

(1) whether the source of water and the potential place of use of the water are located within the same hydrologic basin; and

(2) if there is more than one party and the parties are requesting funds on a joint basis, whether the parties have demonstrated political and economic interests in common by entering into a binding intergovernmental agreement for carrying out the planning process.]"

SECTION 6. A new section of Chapter 72, Article 14 NMSA 1978 is enacted to read:

"[NEW MATERIAL] REGIONAL WATER PLANNING PROGRAM--WATER PLANNING REGIONS--SOLICITATION OF PROPOSALS FOR PLANNING.--

A. There is created a "regional water planning program", the purpose of which is to develop regional and sub-regional water plans that identify the actions needed to be taken at regional and sub-regional levels to provide a reliable water supply for current and future users and to preserve a water supply for future generations of New Mexicans. The interstate stream commission shall be the coordinating agency for the regional water planning program.

B. The interstate stream commission shall:

(1) support and integrate public involvement in water planning;

(2) develop or sponsor the development and utilization of reliable water resources and water use data and scientifically appropriate fact- and science-based water models for the basis of planning;

(3) identify gaps between water supply and water demand and collaboratively implement balanced, realistic solutions to address those gaps; and

(4) prioritize the implementation of approved regional water plans.

C. The interstate stream commission shall create water planning regions by adjusting the regional water planning boundaries that exist as of July 1, 2019 to create no more than sixteen water planning regions that together make up the entirety of the state and that individually include the entirety of:

(1) a distinct geographic area in which depletions of water resources affect the state's compliance with interstate stream compacts or United States supreme court decrees that apportion water among states; or

(2) one or more geologically distinct ground water resources or ground water systems within the state's boundaries, except for the Ogallala aquifer.

D. The interstate stream commission shall solicit proposals from approved regional and sub-regional water planning entities within each water planning region to receive state funding to prepare a plan to address regional or sub-regional water resource problems or issues identified by:

(1) the regional water planning entity;

(2) a sub-regional group with interests in a hydrologically distinct water source;

(3) the interstate stream commission; or

(4) another state agency with jurisdiction over natural resources."

SECTION 7. A new section of Chapter 72, Article 14 NMSA 1978 is enacted to read:

"[NEW MATERIAL] REGIONAL WATER PLANNING PROGRAM--WATER PLANNING REGIONS AND SUB-REGIONAL ENTITIES--REQUIREMENTS.--

A. The interstate stream commission shall establish minimum requirements for approved regional and sub-regional water planning entities, including a determination by the commission that an entity reflects the diversity of the interests within the region or sub-region and that the entity is capable, with or without state support, of developing a regional water plan or addressing a distinct regional or sub-regional water issue.

B. The interstate stream commission shall assist stakeholders within a water planning region to organize a water planning entity and prepare a regional water plan for a region:

(1) in which water use is subject to interstate stream compact limitations that are or may be problematic within four years of the enactment of the Regional Water Planning Act;

(2) that is utilizing ground water resources with a remaining lifetime at or less than one hundred years; or

(3) that organizes to apply to the interstate stream commission to fund a revised regional water plan.

C. The interstate stream commission shall:

(1) provide to approved regional and sub-regional water planning entities the data, water resources models, water resources simulation results and water budgets for the water resources within the region and shall include an explanation or interpretation of any uncertainty in the data or models; and

(2) evaluate the quality and limitations of existing data and models that comprise the factual or scientific basis of the water budget of the water resources within each region and provide this information to the regional and sub-regional water planning entities, as applicable.

D. Locales or sub-regions within a water planning region that have a hydrologically distinct water source may self-organize a sub-regional entity to address problems that are distinct to the locale or sub-region. A sub-regional entity:

(1) shall meet the interstate stream commission's criteria for sub-regional water planning entities;

(2) shall be recognized by regional water planning entities that shall give public consideration to the sub-regional entity's proposals and work products; and

(3) is eligible to receive state funding to implement a work plan:

(a) contained in a regional water plan approved by the interstate stream commission; or

(b) submitted as part of a proposal to the interstate stream commission to address a gap between the supply and demand for the locale's or sub-region's hydrologically distinct source of water.

E. Approved regional and sub-regional water planning entities within the same water planning region whose water planning proposals are accepted for funding by the interstate stream commission shall:

(1) coordinate their planning efforts to promote cooperation and resolve conflicts through negotiation;

(2) develop shared strategies for achieving common objectives; and

(3) monitor implementation of the completed regional water plan and its effectiveness in reducing gaps between supply and demand and in resolving intra-regional conflicts.

F. The interstate stream commission may provide nominal funding to approved regional or sub-regional water planning entities for the preparation of proposals for state funding to prepare regional or sub-regional water plans."

SECTION 8. A new section of Chapter 72, Article 14 NMSA 1978 is enacted to read:

"[NEW MATERIAL] REGIONAL WATER PLANNING PROGRAM-- PROPOSALS--EVALUATION CRITERIA.--The interstate stream commission shall evaluate proposals for state funding of regional or sub-regional water planning against criteria detailed in the commission's solicitation of proposals that shall include, at minimum, consideration of:

A. the adequacy of the planning process to meet the objectives of the Regional Water Planning Act;

B. regular opportunities for public participation;

C. reasonable proposed costs and timetables for completion of the planning deliverables;

D. appropriate provisions for notice, review and comment where applicable;

E. an adequate review of potential conflict with laws relating to existing water rights;

F. an adequate review of water conservation and the effect on the public welfare;

G. identification of sources other than the interstate stream commission for funding of the proposal;

H. the importance and urgency of water resources issues proposed to be addressed;

I. the adequacy of existing water resources data and models to support fact- and science-based water resources planning;

J. the public welfare of the state; and

K. the degree to which state funding of the proposal will result in a regional water plan, or will result in completion of a distinct element of a regional water plan, that if implemented would:

(1) eliminate or reduce the gaps between the water demand within, or projected to occur within, a region or a sub-region and the water supply for the region or a sub-region that is, or is projected to be, physically and legally available over the long term;

(2) solve other water resources problems within the region; or

(3) resolve conflicts between the water use or plans of water supply entities within the region and the sustainable or long-term water supply available."

SECTION 9. A new section of Chapter 72, Article 14 NMSA 1978 is enacted to read:

"[NEW MATERIAL] REGIONAL WATER PLANNING PROGRAM--IN CASE OF NO RESPONSIVE PROPOSALS--INTERSTATE STREAM COMMISSION DUTY TO PREPARE REGIONAL PLAN.--

A. If the interstate stream commission solicits a regional water planning proposal to address imbalances between the water uses and the sustainable water supply of a region or other water resources problems, and if no responsive proposal is received and the interstate stream commission determines that the public welfare of the state may be negatively affected by those imbalances, the interstate stream commission may undertake regional water planning activities in that region to publicly address the imbalances.

B. If the interstate stream commission undertakes regional water planning activities in a region pursuant to this section, the interstate stream commission:

(1) shall conduct multiple public meetings within the water planning region to present and hear public comment regarding:

(a) the need for the state to prepare the water plan for the region;

(b) the topics the water plan will address;

(d) a draft regional water plan;

(2) shall provide substantive, public, quarterly progress reports until the plan is completed;

(3) shall post on the interstate stream commission's website substantive responses to substantive public comments received by the interstate stream commission, orally or in writing, regarding the interstate stream commission's regional water planning activities; and

(4) may include recommendations in the regional water plan that would require future agreement or voluntary actions, including participation in water banks or expedited marketing and leasing."

SECTION 10. A new section of Chapter 72, Article 14 NMSA 1978 is enacted to read:

"[NEW MATERIAL] REGIONAL WATER PLANNING PROGRAM--REGIONAL WATER PLAN--CONTENTS--INTERSTATE STREAM COMMISSION APPROVAL.--

A. A regional water plan shall contain:

(1) a summary of the region's historical water budget as determined by the state based on the region's water use, its renewable water supplies and the amount of water diverted and consumptively used from nonrenewable supplies;

(2) historical water budgets for hydrologically distinct locales within the region where water supplies are in decline;

(3) an evaluation of future potential outcomes associated with no changes in water administration practices and the projected effects of climate change on both water supply and water demand;

(4) prioritized recommendations for actions to reduce the gaps in water supply and demand, taking into account changes in climate and weather;

(5) prioritized recommendations for actions to protect and ensure the efficient use of the regional water supplies and to make the region's water uses more resilient;

(6) prioritized recommendations to improve water resources investigations, monitoring, data and simulation models to reduce uncertainty associated with water budget projections and water supply plans of the water supply entities within the region; and

(7) a plan to measure and monitor implementation of each water planning recommendation.

B. Regional water plans for the lower Rio Grande region, downstream of Elephant Butte dam to the state's border with Texas, and the middle Rio Grande region, between Elephant Butte dam and the Otowi gage, shall also include statutory or voluntary measures that, if implemented, would limit annual consumptive use of water pursuant to state water rights to the supply that is physically available and does not exceed the water supply legally apportioned by the Rio Grande Compact or a decree of the United States supreme court. The water plans shall include provisions for water banking transactions that may be promptly approved and implemented between senior water rights owners and water rights owners whose rights may not be in priority in a given year.

C. Regional water plans shall be submitted to the interstate stream commission for approval. The interstate stream commission shall:

(1) review regional water plans for compliance with its criteria and guidelines and shall prepare a detailed written evaluation of each submitted draft regional water plan addressing each recommendation contained in the regional water plan;

(2) meet with each regional water planning entity to review the commission's evaluation of the water plan and to approve, disapprove or approve with exceptions the regional water plan for incorporation into the state water plan. A regional water plan recommendation shall be disapproved if the recommendation is contrary to the law, does not have an adequate scientific basis or is counter to the public welfare of the state; and

(3) implement or assist water planning regions with implementing approved regional water planning recommendations."

SECTION 11. A new section of Chapter 72, Article 14 NMSA 1978 is enacted to read:

"[NEW MATERIAL] REGIONAL WATER PLANNING PROGRAM-- MEETINGS--OPEN MEETINGS ACT.--

A. A meeting convened by a regional or sub-regional water planning entity and any meeting involving a member of the interstate stream commission for the purpose of developing a regional or sub-regional water plan or any component of a regional or sub-regional water plan shall be subject to the Open Meetings Act.

B. At a minimum, the interstate stream commission shall convene public meetings of stakeholders to:

(1) address the tasks to be addressed in funded proposals;

(2) present the interstate stream commission's evaluation of regional water plans or phases of the water plans submitted to the commission for approval; and

(3) implement the recommendations contained in approved regional water plans."

SECTION 12. A new section of Chapter 72, Article 14 NMSA 1978 is enacted to read:

"[NEW MATERIAL] REGIONAL WATER PLANNING PROGRAM--WATER PLANNING ADVISORY COMMITTEE.--

A. The interstate stream commission shall convene a "water planning advisory committee" composed of representatives from each water planning region.

B. The interstate stream commission shall:

(1) convene public meetings of the water planning advisory committee at least twice a year to seek advice and comments regarding the interstate stream commission's water planning programs and progress;

(2) seek the advice of the water planning advisory committee prior to finalizing its annual water planning appropriation request; and

(3) allow members of the water planning advisory committee who are elected officials of a planning region to place items on the agenda for meetings of the advisory committee.

C. Public members of the water planning advisory committee are entitled to receive per diem and mileage pursuant to the Per Diem and Mileage Act."

SECTION 13. APPROPRIATION.--Ten million dollars ($10,000,000) is appropriated from the general fund to the interstate stream commission for expenditure in fiscal years 2020 through 2024 for state and regional water planning. Any unexpended or unencumbered balance remaining at the end of fiscal year 2024 shall revert to the general fund.

- 27 -